The CME U6MIDI Pro is the default pick. Most home studios land on two or three pieces of MIDI gear sooner or later, a keyboard plus a drum machine or a second controller, and the U6MIDI Pro is the cheapest box that routes between them instead of just passing one cable through. 3 in / 3 out over a single USB-C port covers that rig with room to grow into it.
The Roland UM-ONE Mk2 is the right call for one instrument and nothing else, a simple one-cable interface that does the one job it has cleanly. The iConnectivity mioXM is for a studio built around routing itself, several synths, a couple of computers, maybe a stage rig, where the Ethernet networking and four USB host ports earn their price. For a lighter routing job than the mioXM but heavier than a single cable, the iConnectivity mio in our catalog covers one USB-MIDI connection at a lower price than either the UM-ONE or the U6MIDI Pro, and the CME WIDI Master, CME WIDI Jack and Yamaha UD-BT01 cover the wireless route for anyone who wants to lose the cable rather than add a router. The Kenton THRU-5 is worth knowing about too, a dedicated 1-in, 5-thru box for anyone who needs to fan one clock or controller out to a rack of synths rather than route between a handful of them.
Basis: no single dominant Reddit thread drove this pick set. Specs are the manufacturers' own, owner review counts and star ratings are pulled from Amazon as of August 2026, and picks are placed on the price ladder from budget to premium. Ratings score each interface on the merits with price left out, so the premium pick sits highest and the tier label only tells you where it sits on price. We track listings and prices; we have not hands-on tested these.